Why manager training doesn't stick
Someone becomes a manager this week. Their first 1:1 is in a few days. The workshop that explains the job is not.
Most manager training arrives at the wrong time. It comes too late, months after the move into management, or too early, long before the conversation it was meant for. If managers don't apply new information quickly, most of it is forgotten within weeks.
People learn when they are in the situation. So the test of a manager program is timing: does the guidance turn up on the day it's needed? Our co-founder Joris Luijke sets out the argument in Manager training is broken.
HR becomes the reminder system
Timing is the hard part. To help at the moment of need, somebody has to know the moment is happening: a new hire joins the team, a report comes back from parental leave, salary reviews open.
When that depends on managers remembering, HR ends up chasing. Managers feel pestered, and HR feels responsible for work it can't own.
And the job is getting bigger
Companies are cutting management layers. Some managers now lead up to 20 people, where six to eight used to be normal. A wider span only works if the support changes with it. Joris makes that case in Companies are "unbossing". Most do it poorly.
How Pyn runs it on the HRIS you already have
Pyn connects to your HRIS, so it knows when something happens on a manager's team: a promotion, a new hire, a leave date, a year in role. You set a moment up once. From then on, the manager involved gets the nudge, the context, and the words on the day.
Sent by a person, where managers already work
Messages arrive as a Slack DM, in Microsoft Teams, or by email. They can come from a real person, such as a senior leader or someone in L&D, or from a team sender such as "L&D Team". If the manager replies, the reply goes back to the sender.
Different for every manager, the same setup for you
Content varies by role, department, location, and tenure. A new manager in engineering can get a slightly different message from a new manager in marketing, from the same automation.
Followed up, without the chasing
Add a button to a message and Pyn tracks who has clicked, then reminds anyone who hasn't. You can see who has acted without sending a single chasing email.
On the stack you have
No rip-and-replace. Pyn reads your HRIS and acts where people already work. It works with BambooHR, HiBob, Rippling, Workday, Greenhouse, and Ashby, in Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email. See every integration.
A new manager program that starts on promotion day
The New Manager Program starts the day someone's direct report count goes from zero to one in your HRIS. There is no list of promotions to pull, and no cohort to wait for.
A first month to start from
Here is a first month from our library. Change the weeks, the words, and the sender to fit how your company manages.
- Week one
- Congratulations on becoming a manager: responsibilities, hand-off meetings, and a kick-off 1:1 with each report. Then five things to do in your first week.
- Week two
- How to run a good 1:1, starting from a first 1:1 template, and how to run a first team meeting.
- Week three
- Performance and career development conversations, and managing a team.
- Week four
- Challenging conversations with direct reports, such as managing low performance.
The manager's manager gets their part too
A new manager learns the job from their own manager. So the same promotion can start a month of messages for that person too, beginning with how to support your new manager in their first month. Someone who now manages managers can get what changes when you manage managers.
MongoDB built its program this way: nine automated messages, with weekly education for newly promoted managers and reminders to second-line managers to check in with them.
“We chose Pyn because it allows us to have a truly automated program, delivering core learning opportunities to people the moment they are promoted to manager.”
Everything around the messages
Pyn also adds new managers to the right Slack or Teams channel and to the calendar invite for manager training, which keeps cohorts easy to manage. It can enroll them in an LMS course and run a quick poll on how the transition is going.
Carta sends each new people manager a Slack message introducing its People Management Group, where they find training and support.
“Pyn enabled us to provide managers with the foundational information they needed at exactly the right time. Without Pyn, we would need to message each new manager one at a time, and then keep track of that communication. Pyn automates that manual work, so that we can focus on being a strategic and consultative resource for our managers.”
A nudge for every team moment
The first month ends. The job doesn't. Most of managing is a string of moments that arrive without warning, each one rare enough that nobody remembers the steps. Manager Nudges sends the guidance when the moment comes up in your HRIS.
- A new hire joins
- What to do before the new hire arrives, then a check-in prompt at 30 days. The rest is on our onboarding page.
- Three months in
- Time for a lightweight career conversation.
- Salary review
- How to talk with your employee about their salary review results, before the conversation.
- Leave and return
- A heads-up that a report is returning from parental leave soon, and a plan for a return from a leave of absence.
- Someone leaves
- How to offboard an employee well, so exits are handled the same way on every team.
- Holidays and anniversaries
- Reminders for upcoming holidays, observances, birthdays, and work anniversaries, including a holiday in a report's country that the manager doesn't share.
Send it only when they can act
A nudge a manager can't act on is noise. Send a prompt only when there is something to do, such as a growth conversation when a report reaches a year in role. Count how many messages each manager gets in a week, and aim for fewer.
What Pyn doesn't do
Pyn doesn't have the conversation, and it isn't a workshop where managers practice on each other. It makes sure the manager walks in prepared.
The week ahead, in one message
Every report has dates of their own, and a manager with a full team is not tracking them.
The Weekly Manager Digest gives each manager an automated "My Week Ahead". It pulls the essentials from your HRIS and connected systems and delivers them in Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email: the milestones coming up on their team, with just-in-time coaching for each report.
Managers stay informed without tracking anything by hand, and without drowning in data. Use the digest for what a manager needs to know this week. Keep a nudge of its own for a moment that needs preparation.
Coaching guides from your own framework
A promotion on the team is a manager moment too. The morning after, the manager needs to know what changed at the new level and what to coach toward.
The Manager Coaching Guide Generator is free. Paste your competency framework or career ladder, name the level transition, and get a coaching guide in one of three formats:
- a full guide with a section for each competency, to share or file in a wiki
- a Slack-ready summary of under 200 words
- a month-one plan across the first four weeks
If your People team works in Anthropic's Cowork app, the same job comes as a free Manager Coaching Guide Skill.
Treat the output as a first draft. Someone who knows the role should read it before a manager does.
Measure the moments, not the training hours
Hours of training delivered tells you what HR did. These three tell you what managers got.
- Coverage
- The share of important moments that are actively supported. Did every new manager get the program, in every team and location?
- Follow-through
- Did managers act? A button on a message shows who has clicked and who needed a reminder.
- Sentiment
- Ask at the moment, not at year end. A quick poll on how the transition is going tells you what to change in the program.
Coverage tells you whether support was delivered. Sentiment tells you how it landed. The method is set out in Key success metrics for employee enablement and experience.
Then count what it frees up
At the time of its case study, MongoDB had sent 8,157 content deliveries to new and second-line managers.
“By automating support for new managers we don't have to think about it constantly. It just runs and that helps a lot.”
In one year Carta sent more than 3,000 messages to new hires through Pyn. At about five minutes a message by hand, that gave one program manager 271 hours back. He put them into a program for aspiring managers and a revamp of manager onboarding. Read the Carta case study.
To run your own numbers, use the Pyn ROI Calculator.
Start with one manager moment
Keep the manager training you have. These four steps put it in front of managers on the day they need it.
- Connect your HRIS.It stays the system of record. Pyn reads promotions, new hires, and leave dates from it.
- Pick one moment.The promotion into management is a good first one. Start from the new manager onboarding checklist or the manager development pages in our library.
- Check the first few by hand.Read each message as the new manager would, and as their manager would. Keep a person on the first few promotions until you're happy with it.
- Add the next moment.Once new managers are covered, the same setup handles new hires, salary reviews, leave returns, and exits. See every solution.
Book a demo. Bring your HRIS and your current new manager program. We'll show you how it runs on Pyn.
FAQ
- Where do managers get these messages?
- In Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email, wherever they already work. Messages can come from a real person, such as a senior leader or someone in L&D, and a reply goes back to that sender.
- How does Pyn know someone has become a manager?
- From your HRIS. The New Manager Program is triggered the day someone's direct report count goes from zero to one.
- Is it only for first-time managers?
- No. Our new manager onboarding checklist covers four cases: first-time managers, managers new to your company, managers taking on a new team, and managers of managers. Manager Nudges is for every manager, new or not.
- Does Pyn replace manager training?
- No. Pyn delivers guidance at the moment a manager needs it. It can also add new managers to your training invites and enroll them in an LMS course. The workshop and the coaching stay yours.
- Can we use our own content?
- Yes. Bring what you already send, or start from the manager pages in our library. You can change any message and link out to your LMS or intranet for more.
- Will managers get more messages than they can read?
- Only if you set it up that way. Send a prompt only when the manager can act on it, and use the Weekly Manager Digest to put the week ahead in one message.
- Which HR systems does Pyn work with?
- Pyn reads the HRIS you already have, including BambooHR, HiBob, Rippling, and Workday, and delivers in Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email. The integrations page has the full list.