Why journey maps end up in a drawer
Your team spent a day mapping the employee journey. The wall of sticky notes was photographed, the photo went into a shared drive, and nothing an employee experiences changed.
The idea is sound: one picture of everything a person goes through at your company, from before day one to after the last day, and who is responsible for each part. It fails in three places.
Too many moments, and a blank page
A first day alone can involve the new hire, the hiring manager, a buddy, HR, and IT. Across the whole journey there are hundreds of moments like it. Start from nothing and there is a lot of research to do before anyone maps a thing.
All theory, no change
A finished map is information, like engagement survey results. Until each moment has an owner and an action, nothing is different for the person living through it.
Nobody opens it again
The company changes and the map doesn't. Soon it describes how things used to work. We've written up seven reasons a journey mapping exercise fails, each with a way around it.
So most teams fall back on checklists, which track whether a task got done and not whether the experience was any good.
“It’s just a giant checklist. It doesn’t adapt. People feel like they’re being checked off a list.”
What goes on the map
A journey map has three layers. Categories are the big stages, such as onboarding or life events. Inside each category sit the moments that matter, such as the first day. Inside each moment sits what you send and do for it: the new hire's first-week plan, the hiring manager's instructions.
Moments that matter are the ones with an outsized effect on how someone feels about working for you. They tend to be transitions, such as becoming a manager, or firsts, such as parental leave. For each one, ask what it means for three people: the employee, their manager, and the company. Moments that matter: meaning, examples, and how to start goes through them.
The stages most maps cover
- Pre-boarding
- The gap between a signed offer and day one, where many companies go silent. On a map the silence shows. Here is how to support new hires before day one.
- Onboarding
- The first 90 days and beyond: the manager check-ins and the introductions as well as the paperwork. It has a page of its own.
- Growth and development
- Performance reviews, salary reviews, and career conversations. They come around on a known schedule, so managers can be ready for each one.
- Transitions
- Promotions, team changes, and becoming a manager for the first time. Most companies handle these differently every time.
- Leave and life events
- Parental leave, bereavement, a leave of absence. These are high-emotion moments that need support from the manager as well as HR. Our library has messages for important life events.
- Exit
- Offboarding, knowledge transfer, and staying in touch afterward. How someone leaves decides whether they would come back or refer a friend. See how to exit employees with integrity.
Map the common case first, then add variations by role, location, or employee persona. Who is in the room decides who the map works for: see how to create a map that strengthens diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).
Build it with your team
HR can't map the journey alone, because HR doesn't own every moment.
Start with a minimum viable map
List the moments your people will go through in the next year. Are you hiring steadily? Promoting first-time managers? Expecting parental leaves? That list is your first draft.
Remy Bleijendaal, Chief People Officer at data.ai, put it this way: “Instead of going for something perfect, start with something small, get going.” The MVP of an employee journey map has a version for each size of company.
Run one workshop
Put six to 15 people from across the People team in a room for two and a half hours: talent acquisition, HR operations, HR business partners, learning and development, compensation. The session moves through four stages: understand, co-create, prioritize, assign. Everyone leaves with a shared map and a named lead for each priority. The facilitator guide has the deck. How to run the workshop has a sample invite and tips for keeping the room engaged.
Decide what comes first
If you can't decide, start where the most people are affected. Or start at the two ends.
“People remember the beginning, the peak, and the end. If you don’t know where to start, I would say make the first day a great experience and make the exit also a good one, because this helps people remember you.”
For everything in between, score each moment low or high on impact and on effort. High impact and low effort goes first. Prioritizing moments that matter on your employee journey map has the matrix, and four questions to ask your CEO.
Bring in the people outside HR
Managers come on board fastest when they help build the map. Executives, IT, and finance each need to see their own part of it. Expert tips on getting buy-in for employee journey mapping takes the groups in turn, with advice from John Foster, a former chief people officer who led the People function at IDEO, Hulu, and TrueCar.
Map it in Pyn, without the sticky notes
A whiteboard is a fine place to start a map. It is a poor place to keep one: nobody can filter a wall, and a wall can't tell you who owns what.
The journey map in Pyn is free. It puts the whole journey on one board that your team works on together.
Start from templates, not a blank page
There are ready-made moments and content for each stage of the journey. Add what applies to you, rename it in your company's own language, and leave the rest.
Give every moment an owner, a status, and a priority
Each moment gets an owner, either a person or a team. It gets a current status (in place or not) and a priority. Filter the map to see everything learning and development owns, or everything marked high priority.
“What employees experience across the journey intersects with everyone’s work. So, journey mapping helps us think more broadly about the experience versus siloed thinking in each of our centers of excellence.”
Take it to the people who weren't in the room
Invite your team into the map, then export it for the executive meeting or the budget conversation. Pyn reads the HRIS you already have.
- Journey map with BambooHR
- Journey map with HiBob
- Journey map with Rippling
- Journey map with Workday
- Journey map with Greenhouse
- Journey map with Ashby
What the map doesn't do
It doesn't do the listening. Which moments matter at your company comes from your own people: surveys, interviews, turnover data. And you don't need software to begin. If a whiteboard gets your team in a room this week, use the whiteboard. It is one of the 6 tools you can use to design your employee journey map.
Turn the map into moments that run themselves
A moment on a map helps nobody until something happens when a person reaches it.
Pyn connects to your HRIS, so it already knows the moment someone starts, gets promoted, changes team, or moves on. Switch a moment on and Pyn sends what you designed to the people involved: the employee, their manager, or both. Messages arrive in Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email, from their actual manager or a named person in HR, not as a system notification.
The moments teams add after onboarding
Promotions and work anniversaries. Parental leave, before it starts and on the return. Bereavement and other hard events. Nudges to managers to have a growth conversation or a stay interview. Automated Moments covers more than 50 key moments.
See who is in each moment
Pyn shows how many people are in a moment now, or have been through it lately: how many managers were promoted in recent weeks, how many people are about to reach a five-year anniversary. That count tells you which moments are worth designing first.
“By mapping out touchpoints and reviewing employee journey maps, we’ve been able to pinpoint what was missing, build new communications, and create end-to-end automations where previously nothing had existed.”
Keep the map in use
A map stays alive in the meetings you already have.
- Every month
- John Foster reviews the map in staff meetings: what's working, what's not. “My team knows this is a document we use on a regular basis to evaluate what we’re doing.”
- Every quarter
- Show the progress made and choose what's next. Onboarding this quarter, first-time managers the next.
- At the offsite
- At an HR strategy offsite, review where you have coverage and where you don't, and mark each moment red, yellow, or green.
- At budget time
- Tie each request to a moment on the map, so finance can see what the money is for. How your employee journey map ties to budgeting has worked examples.
- When someone joins the People team
- Foster compares it to a subway map: someone new to the city can see where they are and how to get where they're going. Assigned ownership shows a new team member which stations are theirs.
There is more in How to keep your employee journey map alive and active, including a printed map on the office wall, with sticky notes and pens beside it. Sticky notes are allowed at that stage.
Measure coverage, then sentiment
Engagement and turnover are lagging indicators: the results show up months or years after the work. A journey map gives you two measures you can act on sooner.
- Coverage
- The share of moments that matter that are actively supported when a person reaches them. It is a leading indicator, and it gives each owner on the People team a number that is theirs.
- Sentiment
- How people felt about each part of the journey, asked at the moment and not at year end. Survey every new manager about becoming one, for example.
Coverage says you showed up. Sentiment says whether it helped. In Pyn, each moment on the map carries its own numbers: the employees who went through it, and what was delivered, clicked, and acted on. The method is in Use these 2 metrics to measure your employee experience success.
“It can be hard sometimes in HR to measure progress, but the Employee Journey Map helps you do that.”
Then point the map at the problems you already report on: retention, a consistent experience across offices and managers, and ongoing DEI work.
Start with one moment
You don't need a budget or a three-month project. You need a few colleagues and an hour.
- Ask one question.“What happens between the moment someone accepts our offer and the end of their first week?” Write down every message, meeting, and task, who owns it, and how it's delivered.
- Mark the gaps.Where does nobody own the moment? Where does the experience depend on which manager you get?
- Put it on a shared map.Open the free Employee Journey Map, invite your team, and give each gap an owner and a priority.
- Switch on one moment.Connect your HRIS and automate the moment that reaches the most people. Then choose the next.
Want the long version? Read the Ultimate Guide to Employee Journey Mapping. Comparing tools? Start with the buyer's guide to employee experience platforms.
Book a demo. Bring your map, or the photo of the whiteboard, and your HRIS. We'll show one moment from it running before the call ends.
FAQ
- Is the journey map really free?
- Yes. There's no cost to sign up for or use the journey map in Pyn. Automated Moments, which runs the moments on your map, is a paid tool.
- Do we need software to map the employee journey?
- No. You can start with a whiteboard or a spreadsheet. Software earns its place once the map has to be shared, filtered by owner, and kept up to date.
- How is a journey map different from a checklist?
- A checklist tracks tasks. A journey map tracks experiences: who the message should come from, where it should arrive, what it should say to a remote engineer and to an in-office sales rep, and what happens if nobody reads it.
- How long does it take to build one?
- A basic map for one stage of the journey can be drafted in a few hours. A full map with input from other teams may take a few weeks or more to build well.
- Who should be involved?
- People Ops, IT, hiring managers, and anyone else who touches the employee experience. For a workshop, six to 15 people is the size that works.
- Which HR systems does Pyn work with?
- Pyn reads the HRIS you already have, including BambooHR, HiBob, Rippling, and Workday, and delivers in Slack, Microsoft Teams, or email. The integrations page has the full list.