Pyn • Performance

How do you start a PIP conversation with an employee?

Updated November 2026

A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a written plan with specific goals, support and a timeline, used when earlier feedback hasn't changed things. If you haven't yet decided whether a PIP is right, start with the manager's guide to managing low performance. If you need the document itself, use the performance improvement plan template. This page is about the conversation.

Before the conversation

  • Gather the performance feedback you've already documented and shared in earlier conversations. Nothing in the PIP should be new to your employee.
  • Draft the plan with HR: the gap, the expected standard, the timeline, the check-in cadence and the support you will provide.
  • Decide what support you're offering: training, mentoring, coaching, a change to workload or tooling.
  • Practice the opening with another manager or someone in HR. Say it out loud.
  • If you're in an office, book a room away from the team and near an exit, in case they want to step outside afterwards.
  • Agree with HR whether they will be in the room. For a formal PIP, they usually should be.

How to open the conversation

Get to the point within the first minute. Softening the start doesn't make the news kinder; it makes the employee sit through small talk while wondering what's coming. Here is a script to adapt.

Opening script for a PIP conversation

"Thanks for making time. I want to be direct about why we're here. Over our last few conversations we've talked about [the specific areas], and those haven't yet reached the standard the role needs. Today I want to formalize that into a performance improvement plan."

"I'll walk you through what's in it, what support you'll get from me, and how we'll track progress. I also need to be honest that if the plan isn't met, the outcome could include ending your employment. I'm telling you that now so nothing about this process is a surprise."

"Before I go through the detail, is there anything you want to ask or say first?"

Then stop and listen. Give them time to react and ask questions before you move into the plan.

What to cover during the conversation

CoverHow
The gapName the specific areas and refer back to earlier feedback. Facts and examples, not adjectives.
The standardWhat "meeting expectations" looks like, in terms you can both observe.
The timelineThe length of the plan and the date they'll be formally re-evaluated.
The consequenceSay plainly that termination is a possible outcome if the plan isn't met. Don't hint.
The supportWhat you will do: training, coaching, time, clearer priorities.
The first stepsWhat they can do right away, in one week, in one month. These should be written in the plan.
Their questionsLeave real time for them. Write down anything you can't answer and come back to it.

If your employee becomes upset

  • Stay calm and don't let the conversation escalate.
  • Allow for emotion, but don't argue the facts.
  • Don't apologize for the decision.
  • Empathize without commiserating.
  • Offer a short break of five or ten minutes and reconvene.
  • Let them know they can speak with HR if they wish.

After the conversation

You may adjust the plan based on what your employee said. Once HR has reviewed any changes, both of you sign the final plan and forward it to HR. Encourage your employee to come back to you with further thoughts or questions in the following days.

How to run PIP check-ins

Set up regular check-ins, weekly or every other week, for the life of the plan. In each one, share and document your feedback and their progress against the goals. Ask your employee to lead: how do they think they're doing, what have they realized, what else do they need? Recognize real progress when you see it; it is the thing most likely to keep them going. Check in on how they're feeling too. Morale during a PIP needs managing as much as output does.

How a PIP ends

  • Goals met. Meet HR to formally close the plan. Tell your employee clearly that this is a real achievement, and that the standard now needs to hold beyond the PIP.
  • Some goals met. Consider extending the plan. More time may let them finish the outstanding work and give you a fairer basis to evaluate.
  • Goals not met. Update the plan to reflect that, and talk with HR about whether termination is now appropriate. They will help you prepare.

Frequently asked questions

Should HR be in the PIP meeting?

For a formal PIP, yes in most organizations. They witness the conversation, answer process questions and support both of you. Agree their role beforehand so you still lead the conversation.

Can a PIP be delivered by email?

No. Have the conversation in person or by video, then send the written plan the same day for signature. The document follows the conversation, never replaces it.

How long should a PIP last?

Long enough to show real change and short enough to keep urgency. Set the length with HR based on the role and the gap, and write the re-evaluation date into the plan.

What if the employee refuses to sign the PIP?

The signature acknowledges receipt, not agreement. Say that, and if they still decline, note the refusal on the document with HR present. The plan is still in effect.

Is a PIP just the first step to firing someone?

It shouldn't be, and your employee will be able to tell if it is. Offer a plan only if you genuinely want them to succeed and will give the support to make it possible. If the decision is already made, talk to HR about a different process.

Send this message automatically using Pyn

Share
Back to key moment
Next Performance Pyn
How to prepare for a performance review conversation
View next pyn